- An Eastern Cape education official scored 59 percent in interviews for a senior curriculum-management post, falling below the department’s 60 percent appointment threshold.
- The official argued that her repeated acting appointments and experience made her the most suitable candidate, but her appointment letters made it clear that acting did not create any expectation of promotion.
- The Labour Court in Durban found no reason to overturn the arbitration award and dismissed her review application.
Doing the work of a senior position again and again does not, by itself, mean an employee is entitled to promotion, especially where the employer has clearly stated that acting appointments create no promise of a permanent job.
This principle was central to a judgment by Judge RN Daniels of the Labour Court in Durban, who dismissed an application by Eastern Cape education official Nomawethu Gretta Ketsekile to overturn an arbitration award rejecting her unfair labour practice claim.
Ketsekile challenged the decision to appoint someone else as Chief Education Specialist Curriculum Management, arguing that her experience and performance while acting in the role made her the best candidate.
But the selection process ranked her fourth out of seven candidates, with a score of 59 percent, while the department required at least 60 percent to qualify for senior appointments.
Acting appointments created no expectation of promotion
Ketsekile was Deputy Chief Education Specialist Curriculum Management and Support, a post she had held since 2007. She acted as Principal Curriculum Management from May to September 2021 and as Chief Education Specialist Curriculum Management during several later periods, including from April 2023 to March 2024.
Her appointment letters stated clearly that acting in the higher post did not entitle her to promotion, did not mean she was qualified for the post, and did not create any right or expectation of permanent appointment. When the department advertised the vacant Chief Education Specialist post in July 2023, Ketsekile applied and was shortlisted with six others.
The same selection panel interviewed and assessed all seven candidates. Ketsekile scored 59 percent, while the top three scored 83.3, 77.3, and 64.6 percent. The successful candidate, the fifth respondent, was a black African woman.
The department said the 60 percent threshold applied to senior jobs. Ketsekile did not dispute that the threshold applied.
She argued that the district’s performance had improved while she was acting and that she had relevant experience, unlike the successful candidate, whom she claimed did not have curriculum-management and middle-management experience.
Panel composition and interview process challenged
Ketsekile also questioned the selection panel’s composition, saying it was not properly made up, and the interview questions were too basic.
The judgment records that the panel had seven members, all black African, with three women. Of the three decision-makers, all were black African men. An extra female panellist did not arrive for the interviews, leaving the panel unbalanced in terms of race and gender under the department’s policy.
But the evidence showed the same panel assessed every candidate. No candidates or union representatives objected at the time, and union reps later certified the process was fair.
Judge Daniels found Ketsekile had not shown that the panel’s makeup prejudiced her or that the interview process was unfair. The judgment also noted her claim that the panel favoured a less suitable candidate was speculative and not backed by evidence of unfair assessment.
Experience alone did not establish unfair labour practice
Judge Daniels explained that an employee challenging a promotion must show they were denied a fair chance to compete or that the employer acted unfairly in evaluating them.
The judgment stressed that experience and technical qualifications alone do not entitle an employee to appointment. The employer has some discretion in assessing candidates, as long as the process is fair and follows policy.
The judge found Ketsekile was given a fair chance to compete. Her repeated acting appointments showed experience, but did not create a right to promotion, especially since her appointment letters made that clear. The court found she had not shown the department acted in bad faith, for an ulterior motive, arbitrarily, or in a grossly unreasonable way.
Judge Daniels concluded that Ketsekile had not proved the arbitration award was so unreasonable that no reasonable decision-maker could have reached it.
The Labour Court granted condonation for the late filing of the review application and the respondents’ answering affidavit but dismissed the application to review and set aside the arbitration award.
Get your news on the go. Click here to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel.

