The Labour Court has upheld the dismissal of two former police officers, Cecilia Astle and Abraham Carel Greyling, for failing to thoroughly investigate an assault case.
In a ruling delivered on 12 February 2025, the court examined the procedural and substantive aspects of the employees' dismissal following their involvement in the improper closure of a case related to the alleged assault of Ntsie Esael Sefuthi by members of the South African Police Service (SAPS).
The incident at the heart of this case occurred in February 2017, when Sefuthi alleged he was unlawfully detained and assaulted by officers at the Engen Garage in Fochville. He opened a case at the Westonaria Police Station, which was later transferred to Fochville SAPS. Astle, assigned as the investigating officer, closed the case without proper investigation, falsely stating that there were no known suspects, despite Sefuthi indicating he could identify the assailants.
Following an internal investigation prompted by complaints regarding the mishandling of the case, Astle and Greyling faced charges of misconduct, including negligence and impropriety in managing the investigation. Both were dismissed on 21 February 2020, after multiple delays and procedural complications that raised issues of double jeopardy and due process.
The arbitration proceedings held by the Safety and Security Sectoral Bargaining Council initially found their dismissal to be fair. The court reviewed the arbitration decision, focusing on Astle's and Greyling's defences regarding procedural errors, including claims of double jeopardy and the delay in disciplinary action. However, the court affirmed that the nature of the employees' failures, particularly Astle's decision to close the investigation without due diligence, merited profound consequences.
The court further emphasised that both former officers knew the individuals involved in the incident yet chose to backtrack on the evidence presented by the complainant regarding known suspects, thus blemishing the integrity of the police force. Speaking on the implications of the ruling, Judge M Makhura noted, "This finding underscores that even with a clean disciplinary record, serious lapses in duty cannot be tolerated."
#Conviction
