The Western Cape High Court has issued a decisive estate dispute ruling, addressing complex claims stemming from a deeply tragic family history.
The judgment, delivered on 22 April 2025, concerns the estates of a father and eight-year-old son, whose lives ended in a murder-suicide on 8 September 2019. At the heart of the case are financial disputes involving substantial estate assets originally designated for the child’s future.
The applicant, the mother of the deceased child, had been married to the father for eight years but filed for divorce on 30 July 2019. Acting as both executor of her son’s estate and a claimant against her estranged husband's estate, she sought the recovery of R1 712 000, arguing that the sum, originally gifted for her son's education, had been unlawfully withdrawn from his Standard Bank account before his death.
The defendant, Yulande Aktash, 48, the deceased’s daughter residing in Dubai, countered that the funds belonged to her father regardless of the account being in the child’s name.
Although the account was initially opened for the son, court evidence demonstrated that the father retained full control over all transactions, sparking disputes regarding ownership and legal intent. Aktash argued that, as a minor, the child could not legally hold financial assets independently, leading the court to examine South African estate law to determine whether the funds constituted a legitimate gift under legal stipulations.
During hearings conducted between February and March 2025, the mother testified that her husband had verbally assured her that the funds were intended for their son's education. Aktash, however, maintained that the money had been earmarked for her father’s personal use, emphasising that the child never had direct access to the funds.
Fraud allegations and maintenance claims
Beyond the estate dispute ruling, additional financial claims surfaced, including R142 518.21, which the mother alleged had been wrongfully withdrawn from her Capitec Bank account by her then estranged husband. However, the court dismissed this claim due to insufficient supporting evidence.
The judgment also addressed a claim under the Maintenance of Surviving Spouses Act, awarding the mother R600 000 in spousal maintenance. The deceased’s estate, valued at approximately R4 200 000, was designated for distribution, allowing the mother to receive reasonable maintenance support until her death or remarriage.
After extensive deliberations, the court ruled in favor of the mother, ordering Aktash to return R1 712 000 to the child's estate within seven days. Additionally, Aktash was directed to surrender the disputed Nissan Livina vehicle.
#Conviction
Get your news on the go. Click here to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel.
