- The arrest of South Africa’s National Department of Health Director General over alleged misuse of Global Fund allocations has sparked concerns about donor trust in the country’s health system.
- Prosecutors allege that more than R1 million earmarked for HIV, TB, and malaria programmes was diverted to pay private service providers in an internal labour dispute.
- Trade unions and health advocates fear the controversy could strain relationships with international donors and complicate the 2026 rollout of Lenacapavir.
Donor trust in South Africa’s health funding is under renewed scrutiny following the arrest of the Director General of the National Department of Health, Dr Sandile Buthelezi, on allegations that more than R1 million in Global Fund allocations were misused.
Health advocates and organised labour warn that the fallout from the scandal could reach far beyond the immediate criminal case, potentially jeopardising critical international partnerships at a decisive moment in the country’s HIV response.
Dr Buthelezi was arrested on March 2 by the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation, known as the Hawks. He appeared in the Pretoria Specialised Commercial Crimes Court alongside Chief Financial Officer Phineas Phaswa Mamogale and Acting Deputy Director General for Tertiary Health and Hospital Services, Dr Malixole Mahlathi.
Parties and Allegations
According to the National Prosecuting Authority, the three officials allegedly acted in concert between August and September 2023 to irregularly appoint two private service providers to manage a labour dispute involving a suspended official, Maile Ngake. Payments to these providers, totalling over R1 million, were allegedly sourced from Global Fund allocations.
The Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis, and Malaria provides funding that is strictly ringfenced for specific public health purposes, including healthcare training and outbreak relief. Prosecutors argue that these funds were not permitted to be used for internal disciplinary matters.
The State contends that the diversion of these allocations amounts to theft and fraud. The accused have not yet entered pleas, and the case remains before the court.
At their court appearance, bail was granted to each of the three officials in the amount of R10 000, with strict conditions. They are barred from entering any Department of Health premises, must surrender their passports, and may not contact any witnesses involved in the case. The matter has been postponed to June 3 for further investigation.
Organised Labour Warns of Donor Fallout
The Congress of South African Trade Unions (COSATU) has expressed deep concern about the broader implications of the case for donor trust in South Africa’s health funding. COSATU spokesperson Zanele Sabela welcomed the arrests but described the allegations as a painful betrayal of public trust.
“It is for this reason that COSATU is pained to hear that the most senior health official is embroiled in the theft of funds,” Sabela said. “We call on the NPA to leave no stone unturned to guarantee those guilty of siphoning off funds meant for HIV/Aids, TB, and Malaria patients are prosecuted.”
Lenacapavir Rollout Under a Shadow
The arrests come as South Africa prepares for the mid-2026 rollout of Lenacapavir, a twice-yearly injectable for HIV prevention. South Africa will be among the first countries to receive the drug, supported by a US$29 million (about R540 million) grant from the Global Fund.
Health advocates fear that controversy at the highest levels could undermine confidence precisely when sustained donor cooperation is vital. Ending HIV as a public health threat by 2030 remains a national goal. Achieving that target depends on uninterrupted financing, stable leadership, and continued trust between South Africa and its international partners.
The outcome of the prosecution will determine the legal fate of the accused. In the meantime, the case has thrust donor trust in South Africa’s health funding to the centre of the national health debate.
Get your news on the go. Clickhere to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel.
