In a week that captured the nation's attention with the dramatic rescue of trapped miners in Stilfontein, the Mpumalanga High Court in Middelburg delivered a significant ruling in the battle against illegal mining activities.
On 16 January 2025, the court confirmed a final order against a group of unlawful occupiers engaged in illegal mining on municipal land in Emalahleni, highlighting the ongoing struggle against unauthorised mining operations in South Africa.
This ruling is the culmination of legal proceedings initiated by the Emalahleni Local Municipality against unidentified individuals unlawfully occupying municipal property. The court had previously issued an interim order in October 2024, which allowed for the seizure of mining equipment and assets on the contested property. Legal representatives for the municipality asserted that these illegal activities not only compromised municipal interests but also posed significant threats to public safety.
Despite attempts by the second respondent, Asante Holdings (Pty) Ltd, to argue its case, claiming victimhood in the situation, the court found that the company lacked the requisite standing to challenge the order. Acting Judge M Malangeni emphasised that Asante Holdings had not provided sufficient evidence to support its claim of ownership over the seized equipment. The judge noted that the argument regarding the anonymity of the unlawful occupiers was unfounded, reiterating that legal principle allows courts to address groups engaged in illegal activities, irrespective of their identification.
One of the 246 illegal miners rescued at Stilfontein's Shaft 11 during the final days of the rescue operation. Picture: Screengrab
As the legal proceedings unfolded, the nation's attention was directed to Stilfontein, where a harrowing rescue mission was taking place at the Buffelsfontein mine. After months trapped underground, a total of 87 bodies were retrieved since the operation began, with 246 miners successfully rescued since the beginning of the week. Following a court-ordered rescue operation on 13 January 2025, a total of 78 bodies were retrieved, adding to the nine that were removed earlier.
The miners had reportedly endured dire conditions, without adequate food, water, or medical supplies during their ordeal. An estimated 2,000 miners were working illegally in the disused mine when the drama unfolded a few months as part of Operation Vala Umgodi. Authorities said at the time they would not help the miners because they were “criminals”.
Commenting on the tragedy, the General Industries Workers Union of South Africa expressed profound shock and dismay at the treatment of the rescued miners, who—despite being in critical condition—were subjected to police custody instead of being expedited to hospitals for urgent medical care. The Moral Regeneration Movement in the North West also added its voice, declaring the closure of rescue operations at the disused mine shaft as tragic and traumatic.
"Nothing could have prepared our communities for the catastrophic outcomes that have exposed the modus operandi of the ruthless criminal syndicate that had enslaved mostly victims of human trafficking lured underground to their horrific deaths through falsehoods and deceit," said Pastor Lesiba Kgwele, convenor of the organisation's provincial interim committee.
Kgwele mentioned that survivors of the horrific ordeal are going to require extensive counselling and psychosocial support to reclaim their sanity as well as integrate back to their families and society.
Political parties have called for a commission of inquiry into the Stilfontein mine tragedy. Picture: X
The Workers and Socialist Party and its youth league, Socialist Youth Movement, condemned in the strongest possible terms the heinous atrocities which have unfolded at Stilfontein's Shaft 11. "This campaign of systematic starvation, torture and murder, perpetrated under the guise of Operation Vala Umgodi represents a dark and shameful chapter in South Africa's history, perhaps eclipsing even the horrors of Marikana," they said in a statement. Political parties have called for a commission of inquiry into the tragedy.
Meanwhile, SAPS spokesperson Brigadier Athlenda Mathe said, "Confiscated materials since the start of operations in Stilfontein in December 2023 include over 640kg of gold-bearing material, 6.2kg of refined gold, explosives, firearms and cash amounting to R52.49 million."
#Conviction
