- The High Court confirmed that virtual AGMs are lawful for homeowners' associations.
- A homeowners' association failed to overturn a ruling linked to objections against a virtual AGM.
- The judgment highlights the importance of balancing directors’ powers with members’ rights.
Virtual annual general meetings are lawful for homeowners' associations despite member objections. The High Court in Johannesburg confirmed this in a judgment that addresses the growing use of online governance meetings in residential estates.
Acting Judge J Brickhill dismissed an application for leave to appeal brought by the Brightward Homeowners Association after an earlier ruling partly went against it in a dispute over a virtual AGM. The case arose after homeowners objected to an annual general meeting being held on a virtual platform.
Although the homeowners' association had already succeeded in earlier proceedings in obtaining a declaration that virtual meetings are generally lawful under the Companies Act, the court also ruled that members retained the right to object under the association’s memorandum of incorporation. The association then sought leave to appeal against those findings.
Dispute over virtual meeting objections
At the centre of the dispute was a clause in the memorandum of incorporation allowing members to object to the address at which a meeting would be held. The homeowners' association argued that the clause only applied to physical venues and not to online platforms. Judge Brickhill rejected that interpretation.
The judge found that the association had itself relied on the same memorandum provisions to justify holding meetings virtually and could not later interpret those provisions differently when members exercised their rights.
Judge Brickhill said the association’s approach created an unfair imbalance between directors and homeowners. The judge said the rules could not be interpreted to allow directors to hold virtual meetings while denying members the right to object to those same meetings. The court found that such an interpretation would unfairly favour directors over ordinary members.
Court confirms legality of virtual AGMs
Importantly, the judgment reaffirmed that virtual AGMs are lawful under the Companies Act. The court accepted that homeowners' associations may hold meetings electronically, provided members can communicate properly, participate effectively and exercise their rights.
The court found there was no reasonable prospect that another court would reach a different conclusion on the interpretation of the memorandum of incorporation. As a result, the application for leave to appeal was dismissed with costs, including the costs of two counsel.
Get your news on the go. Click here to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel.
