The Mpumalanga Division of the High Court in Mbombela has ruled that a joint will drafted by the late Patrick Marie Stanislas Henri Reniers and his wife, Francina Elizabetha Reniers, is legally invalid due to failure to meet statutory formalities.
The judgment, delivered on 16 May 2025 by Deputy Judge President TV Ratshibvumo, arose from a dispute between Patrick’s daughter and his wife over control of the estate. Patrick succumbed to Covid-19 complications on 30 July 2021.
Patrick and Francina, married for 15 years, contracted the virus in July 2021. While Patrick was admitted to Mediclinic Hospital, Francina was unable to secure a hospital bed and resorted to self-medication at home. As fate would have it, she survived, but Patrick did not.
Prior to his death, and anticipating the worst, the couple decided to formalise their wishes and sought assistance from LS Giorgio, a financial advisor at Liberty Standard Bank Group, to draft their will. Giorgio provided the document with instructions for both spouses to sign it in the presence of two witnesses.
On 26 July 2021, Francina signed the document at her home in White River and handed it to B Macaulay, a broker at OUTsurance, who took it to Patrick in the hospital. After a lengthy process, Macaulay gained access to the isolated ward, where Patrick signed all three pages without reading them before returning the document.
Macaulay then added his signature, recorded the date and place, and later had his wife sign as a second witness, without either spouse present. The document was subsequently returned to Francina, who preserved it as a valid will. Following Patrick’s passing, the document was submitted to the Master of the High Court and accepted as his last will.
Challenges to the will’s validity
Patrick’s daughter from his first marriage contested the will, arguing that her father would not have excluded all his children from inheritance, particularly given his prior will dated 5 July 1987, which named his children as beneficiaries. She also raised concerns over multiple inaccuracies in the joint will, questioning whether her father had truly authorized its content.
One of the most notable discrepancies was the classification of the marital property regime. The joint will stated that the couple was married out of community of property with accrual, whereas their prenuptial contract, dated 3 May 2006, clearly stipulated they were married without accrual.
Another issue emerged in the naming of the grandchildren as beneficiaries. The will listed four grandchildren as conditional beneficiaries: Marco Groenewald, Lexi Groenewald, Laurica Reynolds, and Odin Reynolds. However, Patrick did not have a grandchild named Lexi Groenewald; his actual grandchild was Lexi du Plessis. Additionally, Laurica’s name was misspelled as “Laurica Reynolds” instead of “Laurika Reynolds.”
The daughter also found it suspicious that Patrick would exclude only one grandchild, Tyler, from the will. Francina claimed this was intentional, citing Patrick’s lack of contact with Tyler since birth, but the omission fueled further doubts about the authenticity of the document. While Francina acknowledged the errors, she dismissed them as typographical mistakes.
Legal proceedings revealed a fatal flaw in the document’s execution. The will lacked signatures from two witnesses present at the time of signing, a statutory requirement under Section 2 of the Wills Act, No 7 of 1953. Despite Francina’s insistence that the will had been properly executed, its non-compliance rendered it legally untenable.
Strict compliance standard applied
Francina filed a counterapplication seeking condonation for the procedural flaws, arguing that the couple’s intent should prevail over formal requirements. However, the court upheld the statutory standard, ruling that intent alone cannot rectify breaches of execution formalities. Deputy Judge President Ratshibvumo reinforced this principle, stating, “The requirements of the statute must be met.”
#Conviction
Get your news on the go. Click here to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel
