The North West High Court in Mahikeng has awarded Batumile Tshepang Kome R480,000 in damages following his unlawful arrest and detention by the police.
The case dates back to 2018 when Kome was arrested on 3 September on alleged charges of assault with the intent to cause grievous bodily harm. Despite his insistence of innocence, he was taken into custody at the Mmabatho Police Station, where he remained in appalling conditions for 24 days. Significantly, he was denied the opportunity for bail or any court appearance during his detention.
Kome's suffering in the holding cells was compounded by unsanitary conditions; and limited space and inadequate facilities meant he was housed alongside numerous other detainees. The presence of a single filthy toilet in the cell, along with the absence of proper showers, created an atmosphere of humiliation that deeply affected Kome's mental and physical well-being. He described an environment rife with threats and bullying from gang members that escalated to his eventual coerced initiation into the gang.
The ruling represents a crucial affirmation of individual rights, as the court underscored the serious infraction of Kome's constitutional freedoms. Judge Wessels considered not only the nature and extent of Kome's suffering but also the significant impact his unlawful detention had on his employment and family life. Prior to his arrest, Kome worked as a gardener and provided for his two young children, but his unjust detention caused him to lose his job, exacerbating his struggles.
In his judgment, Acting Judge M Wessels emphasised the court's responsibility to balance adequate compensation to the aggrieved while preventing excessive financial burdens on the state. The judge's decision to award Kome R480,000 took into account the harsh conditions of detention and the profound emotional distress he experienced, labelling the amount as just and equitable under the circumstances.
#Conviction
