- Advocate Roeloff du Plessis SC can be prosecuted for attempted murder following an alleged road rage incident in Pretoria in August 2023.
- The prosecution follows a decision by former prosecutions head Advocate Shamila Batohi, who found grounds to charge Du Plessis instead of the alleged victim.
- Judge Sulet Potterill dismissed Du Plessis’ challenge, finding that the NPA’s decision was objectively rational and did not infringe his constitutional rights.
Pretoria Advocate Roeloff du Plessis SC, a former acting judge and senior advocate (Silk), can be prosecuted for attempted murder after an alleged road rage incident in 2023, when a motorist was stabbed with a pocketknife.
This was the verdict of the High Court in Pretoria after Du Plessis objected to the National Prosecuting Authority’s decision to prosecute him for attempted murder.
Du Plessis has maintained his innocence from the start and stated he had acted in self-defence. His alleged victim, Conrad Pretorius, suffered gaping knife wounds to his neck and thigh following the incident.
The alleged road rage incident
In August 2023, Pretorius and his wife were driving in Menlo Park, Pretoria, when they encountered Du Plessis, who is a member of advocates chambers in Pretoria, at an intersection where the traffic lights were not working.
It is alleged that an altercation ensued, which resulted in Du Plessis chasing Pretorius through the streets of the suburb for about 5km before allegedly blocking him in a cul-de-sac. It is further alleged that Pretorius and Du Plessis alighted from their vehicles and confronted each other.
Pretorius alleges that Du Plessis stabbed him in the neck with a sharp object, whereafter a struggle ensued, and he was also stabbed in the leg. Pretorius managed to get back in his car and drove to the nearest hospital for treatment. Du Plessis, however, maintained that he acted in self-defence, as his life was being threatened.
While in the hospital, Pretorius filed a criminal complaint for attempted murder against Du Plessis, only to discover that the advocate had also filed a criminal complaint against him. Du Plessis has, meanwhile, launched several legal challenges to avoid prosecution.
Legal proceedings and court rulings
In August 2025, the NPA decided to charge Du Plessis with attempted murder following representations by AfriForum’s Private Prosecution Unit, which represented Pretorius.
The NPA had initially charged Pretorius with assault and malicious property damage. Former prosecutions head, Advocate Shamila Batohi, however, decided that Du Plessis must be prosecuted for attempted murder.
“The central issue in this matter is who acted unlawfully in attacking whom and, in this regard, whether Adv Du Plessis acted in private defence when he twice stabbed Mr Pretorius with his pocketknife,” she said at the time.
Du Plessis turned to the High Court to have the NPA’s decision to prosecute him overturned. He cited various objections to Batohi’s decision, including that he was unlawfully discriminated against, as well as that his dignity and administrative rights were infringed.
Judge finds grounds for prosecution
Judge Sulet Potterill, in her judgment, was asked to determine whether Batohi’s decision to prosecute Du Plessis instead of Pretorius was objectively rational, based on the facts.
“Du Plessis used a knife to fend off, on his version, an unarmed man who was attacking him, and he caused serious injuries in doing so. Du Plessis’ medical report reflects few injuries to himself. The intentional use of a knife when the attacker is weaponless are rational facts upon which Batohi could decide,” the judge said.
She also pointed out that the wounds were on the neck and upper thigh, giving rise to an inference of dolus eventualis being present with respect to attempted murder.
“I am satisfied that the decision was objectively rational and related to the purpose for which the power was granted,” said Potterill in her judgment. Giving the green light for the prosecution, the judge said she could not find that any of Du Plessis’ constitutional rights were trampled on.
AfriForum’s Private Prosecution Unit spokesperson, Barry Bateman, welcomed the judgment and said it is hoped that this brings to an end the legal wrangling so that the trial can resume soon.
Get your news on the go. Click here to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel.

