- Waterfall Residential Developments’ attempt to evict residents was dismissed after questions were raised about whether it had the legal right to do so.
- The argument revolves around whether the developer handed over its eviction rights to Nedbank when it signed the mortgage bond.
- Different court rulings have brought up an important question about the eviction rights of property owners.
Property developers who use their properties as collateral for mortgage loans might run into legal trouble if they want to evict people, especially when their agreements give eviction rights to banks.
This is the main issue in a dispute involving Waterfall Residential Developments (Pty) Ltd, which tried to evict David Jeromin and other residents from a property at Waterfall Country Estate North in Waterfall City, Midrand.
The eviction attempt was thrown out after Jeromin argued that the developer was no longer allowed to bring eviction proceedings because of its mortgage agreement with Nedbank. The developer disagreed, saying the agreement did not actually take away its right to evict.
Mortgage bond at centre of eviction dispute
Waterfall Residential Developments appealed the decision, saying the court got it wrong when it interpreted Clause 8 of its mortgage bond with Nedbank. The company argued that the legal ideas behind a mandate and a cession are different, and that this difference matters in deciding whether the developer still has the authority to evict residents.
The developer pointed to the case of Pacific Paramount Properties (Pty) Ltd v Burchell t/a Top Wash and Another to argue that the right to evict can come from a mandate and is not always a cession. It also questioned how the rules from Picardi Hotels Ltd v Thekwini Properties (Pty) Ltd were being applied, saying new court decisions had made the legal position unclear.
Jeromin opposed the developer, saying Clause 8.2 of the mortgage bond made it clear that the right to evict had been given to Nedbank. He used the case of Nell v Barry NO and Another to back up his argument that this cession meant the developer could not start eviction proceedings itself. This disagreement put the meaning of mortgage agreements and the legal standing of property developers at the heart of the dispute.
Conflicting judgments raise important legal questions
When looking at the application, Acting Judge YF Saloojee looked at Section 17(1) of the Superior Courts Act, which deals with applications for permission to appeal.
This law lets a court give permission to appeal if there is a reasonable chance of success or if there is some other strong reason to allow it. Conflicting court decisions on the same legal issue are seen as a good reason to grant an appeal.
The judgment also discussed a Supreme Court of Appeal decision in Ramakatsa and Others v African National Congress and Another, which said that an important legal question or an issue that might affect future disputes could be a reason to allow an appeal.
Judge Saloojee decided that the different court decisions after the Picardi case had raised an important legal question that affects rental property owners. “I am satisfied that conflicting judgments after Picardi on a legal question that matters for rental property owners is a good reason to grant leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Appeal,” the acting judge said.
Eviction rights remain to be determined
The judge gave Waterfall Residential Developments permission to appeal, which means the company can now take the dispute to the Supreme Court of Appeal. Judge Saloojee also said the costs for this application will be decided in the appeal.
Get your news on the go. Click here to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel.

