- Ka-Mthokozisi picked up his amended LLB certificate on 16 November 2026, after a court ordered UNISA to recognise his legally changed surname.
- Judge NGM Mazibuko dismissed UNISA’s attempt to appeal the order on 27 October 2026.
- In a separate case, the university also got an interim interdict against social media content creator Dr Che Lenyehelo over videos called “Lawyers from Unisa be like”.
After a long legal battle with the university, Trevor Mthokozisi Ka-Mthokozisi has finally collected his amended LLB degree certificate. He declared, “UNISA lawyers are the best; they make history.”
Ka-Mthokozisi picked up the certificate on Monday, 16 November 2026, after UNISA called him on 12 November to let him know it was ready. His comments come at a time when UNISA finds itself in another high-profile dispute about public perception of UNISA-trained lawyers.
The High Court in Pretoria recently gave UNISA an urgent interim interdict against social media creator Dr Che Lenyehelo over videos called “Lawyers from Unisa be like”. The university argued the videos were defamatory and damaged the reputation of the institution, the Faculty of Law, and its graduates.
In that matter, Judge MPN Mbongwe found that the repeated mentions of UNISA in the videos might give the impression that lawyers from the university were incompetent, unreliable, or untrustworthy. The order calls for the videos to be taken down and bans similar posts while the case continues.
Legal battle over amended certificate
The dispute in Trevor Mthokozisi Ka-Mthokozisi v University of South Africa and Others began after Ka-Mthokozisi legally changed his surname from Sibanda to Ka-Mthokozisi in December 2023 through the Department of Home Affairs.
He studied for his LLB at UNISA between 2011 and 2017, and graduated in 2018 under his old surname, Trevor Mthokozosi Sibanda. After changing his surname, he asked the university to amend his qualification certificate to match his new name.
UNISA updated its academic records to reflect the new surname in January 2024. The South African Qualifications Authority (SAQA) and Umalusi also updated their records. But the university refused to issue an amended degree certificate, offering him a statement in place of the certificate, along with his academic transcript and study record.
UNISA argued that he had not used the internal appeals process with the Registrar. The university relied on higher education certification rules and its policy on replacing duplicate certificates, saying the certificate could not simply be re-issued as he asked.
Ka-Mthokozisi went to the High Court in Pretoria to get an order forcing UNISA, its Chancellor and Registrar to issue an amended LLB certificate with his new surname. His case focused on the difference between replacing a lost or damaged certificate and correcting an existing one to reflect a legally recognised change in personal details.
Judge orders UNISA to amend certificate
On 19 June 2026, Judge NGM Mazibuko gave judgment granting the relief Ka-Mthokozisi was seeking. The court looked at UNISA’s reliance on its duplicate-certificate policy and the relevant higher education rules. But the judge made it clear there’s a difference between issuing a duplicate certificate and correcting or amending an existing certificate to reflect a graduate’s new legal surname.
The judge found that Ka-Mthokozisi had lawfully changed his surname and that all the relevant institutions, including UNISA, had updated their records. There was no good legal reason for the university to refuse to update the degree certificate too.
Judge Mazibuko said, “A duplicate is different from a correction or an amendment… I could find no ground upon which Unisa cannot issue an amended degree certificate bearing his new surname.” The court described UNISA’s refusal as “arbitrary, unreasonable, irrational, incoherent”.
The judgment ordered UNISA, its Chancellor and Registrar to issue an amended LLB degree certificate showing Ka-Mthokozisi’s new surname, matching his Home Affairs identity document. The court also made orders about the affidavits and applications in the case. It dismissed UNISA’s application for condonation, struck out its answering affidavit, and refused permission for a supplementary affidavit.
While the court did not grant the broader relief Ka-Mthokozisi asked for in his constitutional challenge, it did order the university to issue the amended certificate. UNISA also had to pay the costs of the application, including the costs of counsel.
UNISA’s attempt to appeal dismissed
Instead of issuing the amended certificate, UNISA applied for leave to appeal Judge Mazibuko’s judgment. The application was heard on 20 October 2026, with UNISA trying to challenge the ruling and the order requiring it to amend the qualification certificate.
Judge Mazibuko considered the application under Section 17(1) of the Superior Courts Act, which says an applicant must show reasonable prospects of success on appeal or give another recognised reason for granting leave.
In a judgment delivered electronically on 27 October 2026, Judge Mazibuko dismissed UNISA’s application for leave to appeal, saying the university had not shown any reasonable prospect of success. The court allowed the late filing of the application but dismissed the actual bid for leave to appeal. UNISA was ordered to pay the costs of the application on Scale B.
Graduate finally collects certificate
Ka-Mthokozisi expressed gratitude to the legal team that represented him throughout the proceedings, particularly Counsel Sindiso Sibanda of MSM Attorneys, who appeared as counsel, and Dickson Makhura of TK Baloyi Attorneys, who acted as the instructing attorney. He also thanked Judge Mazibuko for dispensing justice.
Reflecting on the outcome, he said, “Most importantly, I am grateful to Jesus for giving victory and faith for a good cause.” Ka-Mthokozisi also expressed hope that the outcome would assist other UNISA students and alumni seeking the re-issuance of original certificates without unnecessary hindrances.
Get your news on the go. Click here to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel.

