- Father loses all parental rights after nearly 10 years without contact or support.
- Court accepts evidence of sustained domestic abuse and harmful conduct toward mother and child.
- Husband forfeits pension, property, and all financial benefits from the marriage.
A father who had not seen or supported his son for close to a decade has been stripped of all parental rights, after Judge JI Henriques found that his conduct over the course of the marriage and beyond made it impossible to preserve any legal relationship with the child.
The case unfolded in the High Court in Durban against the backdrop of what Judge Henriques described as a somewhat long and acrimonious history, one marked by repeated violence, control, and a complete breakdown of parental responsibility.
Parties and background
The couple was married in community of property in December 2006, with twin boys born in June 2009. The marriage began to unravel within a few years, with the couple separating in 2012 after a relationship defined by conflict and instability.
By the time the matter reached final determination, the divorce itself was no longer in dispute. The litigation stretched over more than a decade. In his judgment, Judge Henriques explained, “This action has taken some time to be finalised due to, inter alia, a change in attorneys by both parties, the personal misfortunes of the plaintiff, the amendment of the pleadings, the defendant’s lack of legal representation and the Covid-19 pandemic.”
A pattern of abuse and control
The court was confronted with a detailed and disturbing account of sustained abuse throughout the marriage. From the outset, Judge Henriques said, “I do not propose to deal with all the evidence presented during the trial, as it is a matter of record, and will simply highlight those aspects which are relevant to the determination of the issues.”
The abuse began on the honeymoon. The mother testified that the husband grabbed her arm and squeezed it tightly, poured water over her head, cut the cord of her camera, and broke her mangal sutra chain. Her arm remained blue for approximately two weeks.
The violence escalated throughout the marriage. On one occasion, the husband grabbed the mother by her hair, placed her between his legs, and pointed her firearm at her left temple. According to the mother’s testimony, he told her, “You must die for not listening to me.” His parents, who were present, did not intervene at any stage.
In December 2011, the husband punched the mother in the eye with a clenched fist and repeatedly struck her over the head. Photographs produced in court showed a swollen right eye and injuries to both sides of her head. He had also taken scissors and cut her hair off. The mother was subsequently hospitalised for 10 days at St Josephs Hospital for depression.
Having heard all the evidence, Judge Henriques found, “I did not gain the impression that she was lying or trying to paint the defendant in a bad light.”
What made the husband’s position worse was that he never challenged her account. The judge observed, “None of the plaintiff’s evidence of abuse and the incidents she testified about was disputed by the defendant.”
The abuse was not limited to the mother. The mother testified that the father slapped the child and attempted to smother him with a pillow. The child described the incident to the curator ad litem, “He had been lying on his bed when the defendant took a pillow and put it over his head.”
The child said the father pressed harder when he could not breathe. The father also made threatening phone calls to the mother. The curator ad litem recorded, “On the next occasion, he would kill the child so as to teach the plaintiff a lesson.”
The child at the centre of the case
At the heart of the matter was a child who had effectively grown up without a father. It is common cause that the father had no contact with the child for approximately 10 years, apart from seeing him at his twin brother’s funeral.
The father himself admitted as much under cross-examination. Asked why he had done nothing to enforce the contact order for nearly a decade, he told the court, “He felt that he was wasting his time.”
When the curator ad litem pressed him on why he had not exercised contact since September 2016, the father replied, “I walked away.” His explanation for paying no maintenance was just as dismissive. He told the court, “There was no court order requiring him to do so.”
He went further still, making his position plain to the curator, “He is not prepared to pay maintenance, as he will not get the access he desired.” The child, for his part, was equally clear. He told the curator, “The defendant has never contributed to his life, and he had no bond with him.”
When asked whether he would grant permission for his son to obtain a passport, the father answered, “Why would the child want to leave the country?”
He added that he would think about it after the case. When the child was asked to draw a picture of his family at the end of his interview with the curator, the picture omitted the father entirely and included only his pets.
Medical neglect and conflict over care
A significant portion of the case involved the care of the child’s twin brother, who had severe medical needs. Dr Nelandra Chetty, a specialist paediatrician and allergologist, testified that the twin suffered from smooth brain syndrome, epilepsy, severe gastroesophageal reflux, and scoliosis so advanced that his spine was S-shaped. On the question of medication, Chetty testified, “It is critical and of vital importance for the child to remain on the drugs.”
He warned that without oxygen support, the child’s blood pH levels would be affected, his heart function would deteriorate, and eventually he would stop breathing.
Despite this, the father unilaterally removed the child from his medication while in his care. Each time the child returned from the father, Chetty noted, “The child presented as being agitated, hypoxic and ill.”
He attributed this directly to the father’s refusal to administer oxygen and medication. The Family Advocate reported, “The defendant was not familiar with the child’s chronic medication, notwithstanding the fact that he lived with him.”
This stood in direct contrast to the mother, who was not only aware of the medication but also the precise dosages required.
Arguments before the court
The curator ad litem, S Clarence, placed on record her intention to seek the termination of the father’s parental rights. She stated, “He has not seen the child in ten years and has not contributed to the child’s maintenance in any way.”
The husband filed written submissions seeking, among other things, that the court refrain from making an order of forfeiture. He also proposed paying maintenance of R1 per annum until he gained meaningful employment. Judge Henriques noted that the husband had attempted to introduce affidavits and documents not presented at the hearing. The judge ruled, “I did not have regard to these, as they were not presented during the trial.”
Court’s findings on parental rights
Judge Henriques approached the matter through the lens of the child’s best interests. On the father’s failure to fulfil his responsibilities, the judge found, “The defendant failed to contribute to the child’s well-being both in a financial sense as well as in an emotional sense by failing to exercise contact with him, despite the existence of a court order entitling him to do so.”
On the passport issue, the judge held, “The defendant would not consent to a passport for the child, thereby placing his interests above that of his son.”
His conclusion on the termination of parental rights was unambiguous. Judge Henriques stated, “I am of the view that I ought to grant an order terminating the defendant’s parental responsibilities and rights in accordance with s 28 of the Children’s Act, as it is in the best interests of the child.”
He added, “As upper guardian of the minor child, I do not believe that it is in the child’s interests to be forced to maintain contact or a relationship with someone who has made no emotional or financial effort to be in his life.”
Forfeiture of financial benefits
On the question of the joint estate, Judge Henriques found that the husband had made virtually no meaningful contribution. Rejecting the husband’s version outright, the judge said, “I do not believe his assertions that he made any contributions at all to the upkeep, maintenance or the acquiring of such a property in any way.”
On why the property was ever registered in both names, the judge noted, “It was never the intention for him to benefit in any way.”
The property had only been placed in joint names because the husband refused to register an antenuptial contract. Having weighed all of this, the judge concluded, “It would be just and equitable in the circumstances if this court grants an order wherein the defendant forfeits his right, title and interest in and to the plaintiff’s pension fund, retirement annuity and the immovable property.”
The court also noted that the husband had cancelled the life policy in favour of the wife and that at the time of trial, he had no income, was running no business, and was entirely reliant on his father and brother for financial support.
Final order and impact
The court granted a final order terminating the father’s parental rights, referring maintenance to the maintenance court, and awarding forfeiture of all financial benefits to the mother, including her Government Employees Pension Fund, her Liberty Life retirement annuity, and the immovable property in Chatsworth.
The husband was also ordered to bear the wife’s costs of the entire action. In exercising his discretion on costs, Judge Henriques pointed to the history of the matter and the husband’s intransigent behaviour throughout the proceedings.
This judgment makes clear that parental rights are not automatic or permanent. Where a parent engages in sustained abuse, withdraws from a child’s life, and fails to act in the child’s best interests, the law will intervene decisively.
Get your news on the go. Click here to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel.

