- The applicant said she married the deceased in 2006 following lobola negotiations and traditional ceremonies involving both families.
- She relied on his assurance that he had divorced his first wife but never established whether the divorce had been finalised.
- Acting Judge H Zilwa found that she had failed to establish the good faith required for recognition of a putative marriage.
A woman who trusted her partner’s assurance that he had divorced his first wife has lost her bid to have their customary marriage recognised as putative. The High Court in Bhisho found that knowing about his existing civil marriage placed a responsibility on her to verify that it had legally ended before marrying him.
The applicant said the deceased married his first wife in 1993, but they separated in 1998. The wife subsequently instituted divorce proceedings and served him with a summons. According to the applicant, the man told her that he would not defend the divorce because both parties wanted to end the marriage. He later informed her that they had divorced.
The applicant accepted his assurance and did not ask to see a divorce decree. In 2006, the man proposed marriage, and their families entered into lobola negotiations. She said R30 000 was paid as lobola, equivalent to 10 head of cattle, together with a R2 000 fine imposed on the man for impregnating her before the marriage.
She maintained that she was subsequently taken to his family home in Qhanga location, accompanied by her mother and uncles, who represented her family. Traditional ceremonies were performed, and she was formally introduced and handed over to the deceased’s family as his wife. Further traditional processes followed in the months after the ceremony.
Two members of the man’s family who participated in the lobola negotiations supported her account through confirmatory affidavits.
The couple lived in Chintsa from 2006 until early 2018, when they bought a house in Wilsonia, East London. They remained together until the man died on 11 July 2019. Since his death, the applicant’s marital status and entitlement to his estate have been the subject of litigation between her and the respondent, who was appointed executrix.
The first wife opposed the application, maintaining that the applicant had never married the man under customary law and had merely cohabited with him while knowing that he was still married. She disputed that the customary ceremonies had taken place, including the handing over of the applicant and other traditional rites.
She also relied on an earlier application brought by the applicant in 2021, in which she sought to have the respondent’s marriage to the deceased declared invalid and the Department of Home Affairs’ records amended. That application was dismissed with costs.
The existing civil marriage
Acting Judge H Zilwa found that the civil marriage between the respondent and the deceased remained valid when he purportedly entered into the customary marriage with the applicant in 2006.
The judge explained that a putative marriage is a marriage that is legally void but may nevertheless produce certain legal consequences if specific requirements are met. One or both parties must genuinely and mistakenly believe that their marriage is valid and that no legal impediment exists. The parties must also have complied with the formalities required for the solemnisation of the marriage.
However, the judge emphasised that good faith must be objectively reasonable and cannot be established merely by a person’s subjective belief that the marriage was valid.
Failure to establish good faith
Judge Zilwa found that the applicant had relied on the deceased’s verbal assurance without taking reasonable steps to establish whether his previous marriage had legally ended. The judge held that a person who knows about an existing civil marriage has a responsibility to investigate whether it has been legally dissolved before entering into another marriage.
In Paragraph 23 of the judgment, Judge Zilwa stated, “Loving trust, however deep, cannot substitute for the minimal due diligence expected of a reasonable person.”
The judge further held that a person who knows about an existing marriage cannot claim good faith by choosing not to establish whether that marriage has legally ended. The applicant’s failure to request a divorce decree meant that her belief could not satisfy the objective standard of reasonableness.
Although the court accepted, for purposes of deciding the application, that the lobola negotiations and customary ceremonies had taken place as described by the applicant, these could not overcome the absence of the required good faith.
The respondent had also argued that disputes about whether the customary rites had been completed warranted a referral of the matter for oral evidence under Uniform Rule 6(5)(g).
Judge Zilwa rejected the request, finding that the factual disputes were not material to the outcome. Even if the applicant’s version of the customary ceremonies was accepted in full, her failure to satisfy the requirement of bona fides meant that the application could not succeed.
The judge concluded that oral evidence about the lobola negotiations and traditional ceremonies could not cure the legal defect established by the applicant’s own admissions. The purported customary marriage was therefore void from the outset and could not be recognised as a putative marriage.
The application was dismissed, and the applicant was ordered to pay the respondent’s legal costs on Scale A.
Get your news on the go. Click here to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel.

