The Western Cape High Court has affirmed that legal recognition of fathers without DNA testing is now possible.
Delivered on 26 May 2025, the judgment established that fathers could have their names recorded on their children’s birth certificates without mandatory DNA testing, provided a court has confirmed their paternity. The legal recognition of fathers without DNA testing is expected to transform family law, making birth registration more accessible and eliminating financial obstacles.
Paternity dispute and legal battle
The applicants, VK, a Zambian father, and his partner, SM, sought judicial intervention to confirm VK’s fatherhood of their two sons, both born outside of marriage. Their case challenged the requirement for DNA testing in birth registration, arguing that it placed a disproportionate financial burden on VK, who, due to his immigration status, was unable to legally work in South Africa.
The court ruled that under Section 11(5) of the Births and Deaths Registration Act, a father confirmed by a court as a child's legal parent must be recorded on the child’s birth certificate without requiring further proof unless explicitly disputed.
Judge Fareed Moosa, who presided over the case, emphasised that demanding genetic testing as proof of fatherhood insulted not only VK’s dignity but also that of his children. The court further noted that bureaucratic obstacles like mandatory DNA tests disproportionately impact fathers facing economic hardship and legal uncertainty, reinforcing the urgency of modernising family law.
The ruling establishes a precedent that will help fathers in similar situations secure legal recognition without the burden of costly genetic testing. This decision strengthens paternal rights, ensuring that fathers can be acknowledged without procedural barriers that unfairly restrict access to legal parental status.
Protection from deportation and stability for families
In addition to affirming VK’s paternity, the judgment extended an interim interdict preventing his deportation, allowing his application for permanent residency, pending his newly affirmed legal status as a father, to be processed. This move ensures that his children can receive parental support and legal security, avoiding disruptions caused by immigration challenges.
While the ruling does not completely overhaul existing regulations, it clarifies that courts can affirm paternity without requiring genetic verification, a crucial step in removing financial and legal barriers to parental recognition.
#Conviction
Get your news on the go. Click here to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel
