Skip to content
Close Menu
ConvictionConviction
  • Home
  • Law & Justice
  • Special Reports
  • Opinion
  • Ask The Expert
  • Get In Touch

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

What's Hot

Rethinking malaria control in southern Africa through science and regional collaboration

November 14, 2026

Mavericks billboard challenged for sexualising women and exposing children to adult content

November 14, 2026

Black Friday scammers are after more than your bank PIN; they want your face

November 14, 2026
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Trending
  • Rethinking malaria control in southern Africa through science and regional collaboration
  • Mavericks billboard challenged for sexualising women and exposing children to adult content
  • Black Friday scammers are after more than your bank PIN; they want your face
  • UNISA secures interim interdict against ‘Lawyers from Unisa be like’ social media videos
  • How Zuma and Mbalula agree: The ‘kleva blacks’ and their migration to the DA
  • EFF and ALPA lose bid to reinstate Adv Madonsela in Phala Phala impeachment inquiry
  • Scholar transport operator’s bid to recover three impounded minibuses fails
  • Educational specialist who assaulted wife in decorative mat dispute will remain in jail
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
ConvictionConviction
Sonneblom
  • Home
  • Law & Justice
  • Special Reports
  • Opinion
  • Ask The Expert
  • Get In Touch
ConvictionConviction
Home » Menlo Park High School borehole
Property Law

Neighbours retain right to draw water from Menlo Park High School borehole

Kennedy MudzuliBy Kennedy MudzuliNovember 2, 2026Updated:November 2, 2026No Comments
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Tumblr Email
Menlo Park High School borehole
Neighbours retain their right to draw water from a borehole on Menlo Park High School grounds. Picture: Facebook
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email
  • The High Court dismissed Menlo Park High School’s attempt to appeal the decision that safeguards the neighbours’ access to the borehole.
  • The dispute focused on a registered servitude that gives the neighbours the right to draw water from the borehole and to access its pumping equipment.
  • The school governing body has been ordered to pay the costs of the failed appeal on Scale C.

The neighbours of Menlo Park High School will keep their right to draw water from a borehole on the school’s property after the High Court rejected the school governing body’s effort to challenge an earlier ruling.

The court found there was no reasonable prospect of a successful appeal and no compelling reason for another court to reconsider the dispute.

Dispute over borehole access

The dispute involves a registered servitude that gives two neighbouring property owners, Bernard Theunis Botha and Leonore Botha, the right to draw water from a borehole located on the school’s property.

The neighbours took the matter to the High Court after a disagreement with Die Hoërskool Menlopark over access to the borehole, its pump, and the pipeline that supplies water to their property. They asked the court for an order to restore their access and to prevent the school from interfering with their water supply.

The school responded with a counter-application, asking the court to cancel the servitude under the National Water Act. As an alternative, it wanted the court to regulate and restrict access to the borehole.

The original application succeeded, and the court granted protection against interference with the neighbours’ water rights while also regulating access to the borehole. After Botha died, his executor, Michiel Coenraad Botha, was named as the first applicant in his place.

School challenges the ruling

The school governing body later applied for permission to appeal, arguing that the original judgment had several errors relating to the interpretation of the servitude, municipal water by-laws, and the neighbours’ rights.

It also disputed the finding that more drilling by the school could affect the amount of water available to the neighbouring properties. However, Acting Judge LG Kilmartin found no merit in these arguments.

Regarding the issue of more drilling, the court considered evidence given by Dr Roger Diamond from the University of Pretoria. He found that further drilling could have a serious negative effect on existing boreholes.

The school did not provide any evidence to challenge his findings. Judge Kilmartin said the registered servitude gave the neighbours a right that can be enforced, and the school had to make sure its actions did not undermine that right.

The court also rejected the governing body’s argument that the original judgment had incorrectly interpreted the neighbours’ access rights. The court explained that the order did not give the neighbours unlimited access, but rather allowed for reasonable access to the borehole and pumping equipment.

No grounds for another appeal

The school also argued that the neighbours had not paid for the water supplied through the servitude. However, correspondence going back to 1977 showed that the school had acknowledged the neighbours’ rights over many years. There had never been any demand for payment during that time.

Judge Kilmartin pointed out that the school had not brought a claim for any alleged outstanding payments. The court repeated that an application for leave to appeal requires more than just the possibility that another court might reach a different conclusion.

Quoting the Supreme Court of Appeal’s decision in MEC Health, Eastern Cape v Mkhitha, the court said that someone applying for leave to appeal must show there is a “reasonable prospect or realistic chance of success”.

The judge concluded that the governing body had not shown a reasonable prospect of success or any compelling reason for an appeal to be heard. The court also found that the dispute was about the specific rights of the parties involved and did not raise an issue of broader public importance.

The application for leave to appeal was dismissed, and the school governing body was ordered to pay the costs on Scale C.

Conviction.co.za

Get your news on the go. Click here to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel.

Borehole Servitude leave to appeal Menlo Park High School Property rights water rights
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Telegram Email
Kennedy Mudzuli

Multiple award-winner with passion for news and training young journalists. Founder and editor of Conviction.co.za

Related Posts

Farmer secures right to transport allocated irrigation water across Transnet land

November 13, 2026

Former trustee ordered to return body corporate property bought without proper approval

November 12, 2026

A 1960 will puts R8.6m Hout Bay land restitution claim at risk of further legal dispute

November 9, 2026
Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Prove your humanity: 9   +   6   =  

Subscribe to our newsletter:
Top Posts

Your driving licence at the gate: What estates can actually legally scan

Sponsor: My Estate LifeSeptember 6, 2026

Making sectional title rules that work: A practical guide

January 17, 2025

Protection order among the consequences of trespassing in an ‘Exclusive Use Area’

December 31, 2024

Between a rock and a foul-smelling place

November 27, 2024
Don't Miss
Opinion
7 Mins Read

Rethinking malaria control in southern Africa through science and regional collaboration

By Professor Tiaan de Jager and Dr Taneshka KrugerNovember 14, 20267 Mins Read

Southern Africa has made progress in malaria control, but extreme weather, population movement and resource constraints are creating new challenges for elimination.

Mavericks billboard challenged for sexualising women and exposing children to adult content

November 14, 2026

Black Friday scammers are after more than your bank PIN; they want your face

November 14, 2026

UNISA secures interim interdict against ‘Lawyers from Unisa be like’ social media videos

November 14, 2026
Stay In Touch
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • WhatsApp
Demo
About Us
About Us

Helping South Africans to navigate the legal landscape; providing accessible legal information; and giving a voice to those seeking justice.

Facebook X (Twitter) YouTube WhatsApp Twitch RSS
Latest posts

Your driving licence at the gate: What estates can actually legally scan

Sponsor: My Estate LifeSeptember 6, 2026

Making sectional title rules that work: A practical guide

January 17, 2025

Protection order among the consequences of trespassing in an ‘Exclusive Use Area’

December 31, 2024
OUR PICKS

Two employees dismissed for secretly recording a workplace meeting via cellphone

November 9, 2026

Emmanuel Assemblies church founders ordered to surrender offices amid takeover

November 6, 2026

Bestmed ordered to reinstate member after unjustified medical aid cancellation

October 26, 2026
© 2026 Conviction.
  • Home
  • Buy Now
  • Law & Justice

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

Powered by
Necessary cookies enable essential site features like secure log-ins and consent preference adjustments. They do not store personal data.
None
Functional cookies support features like content sharing on social media, collecting feedback, and enabling third-party tools.
None
Analytical cookies track visitor interactions, providing insights on metrics like visitor count, bounce rate, and traffic sources.
None
Advertisement cookies deliver personalized ads based on your previous visits and analyze the effectiveness of ad campaigns.
None
Unclassified cookies are cookies that we are in the process of classifying, together with the providers of individual cookies.
None
Powered by