- Sello Daniel Mashabela was dismissed after buying three pies at R7 each at Makro Alberton.
- The Labour Court held that the arbitrator was wrong to impute a collective intention to defraud to three of the employees without establishing Mashabela’s own state of mind.
- Makro have been ordered to reinstate Mashabela as Sales Manager: General Merchandise, with no order as to costs.
Sello Daniel Mashabela who was at Makro Alberton for 11 years was sacked in July 2023 after buying three Pieman’s Fresh Baked pies at R7 each. The normal price for a case of 12 is R283.95.
The incident occurred on 10 April 2023 when a number of staff members purchased the pies from the bulk freezer. The individual pies were scanned at R7 as a single unit product code remained on Makro’s system post-merger.
Mashabela (Sales Manager General Merchandise) said that assistant front end manager Sibongile Radebe had told him the pies were on markdown. He went with Radebe and another member of staff, Katisi Mashele, to the freezer where a case was removed and opened.
He bought three pies off the staff card (paid at the till, got an invoice and left). He was subsequently found guilty of dishonesty for taking three pies from the bulk box and then purchasing them at a price which was massively below their normal value.
A disciplinary hearing found him guilty on 25th July 2023 and he was dismissed on 28th July. His internal appeal was unsuccessful.
Arbitrator failed to assess individual responsibility
Mashabela challenged his dismissal at the CCMA together with two other colleagues, Ms Mooki and Ms Matlala. Commissioner Dumisani Johannes Ngwenya went along with the dismissals, saying the employees should have known that you couldn’t legitimately buy a pie in bulk individually for R7.
The commissioner was of the view that their failure to check the price was a deliberate attempt to defraud Makro. However Acting Judge MH Mhambi found that the arbitrator had treated the three employees as a group, irrespective of their individual positions and levels of involvement.
The judgment observed that Mashabela had got the information regarding the markdown straight from Radebe, the other staff having got involved in their own particular way.
The commissioner also had the opening of the bulk box as evidence of dishonesty. Makro’s own witnesses testified that Mashele had opened it prior to Mashabela’s arrival. The judge found that the commissioner had not properly established what Mashabela personally knew at the time of the purchase.
Failure to check the price did not prove dishonesty
The central issue was whether Mashabela knew (or indeed appreciated) that the R7 was wrong when he bought the pies. Judge Mhambi made it clear that failure to check a price could be a matter of carelessness but did not in itself amount to dishonesty.
“An employee who fails to check a price before purchasing an item may be thought of as being careless, if not downright foolish. That failure in itself is not (without more) dishonest,” the judgment said. The court found that Mashabela had got the information from Radebe who was the assistant front end manager and had also bought the six pies at the same price.
Radebe said, “Buying pies isn’t dishonest… I didn’t know the price was wrong.” The judgment also established that the R7 price had been on Makro’s system for months and that Makro’s own witnesses gave conflicting accounts as to how the pricing issue had arisen.
Mashabela had also paid at a till, got an invoice and went through security. The judge found that the circumstances did not support the conclusion that he had knowingly participated in a scheme to defraud his employer.
Employer could not rely on misconduct outside the charge
Makro also relied on Mashabela’s conduct following the fact that he had been informed the pies had been incorrectly priced. He didn’t go to management to report it or to offer to pay the difference. He also refused to give an investigator a statement.
The judgment did acknowledge that his reply was not to be admired and described his behaviour as obstinate. However, the court held that his subsequent behaviour could not support a dismissal on the grounds of misconduct which had not been the subject of the disciplinary charge.
Mashabela was charged with dishonesty in relation to the purchase of the pies. He was not charged with the failure to disclose the pricing error, the failure to return the goods, the failure to pay the difference or the failure to co-operate with an investigation.
“An employee is entitled to be judged on the charge that he was called upon to answer,” read the judgment. The court also observed that Makro’s management had never formally requested Mashabela to refund the pies or to pay the difference.
Judge Mhambi was of the view that the evidence did establish that Mashabela had failed to exercise the care which would be expected of a manager, but that it did not prove that he knew the price was wrong when he went ahead and purchased it.
Makro ordered to reinstate former manager
The Labour Court found that Commissioner Ngwenya had materially misconceived the enquiry and that the conclusion he reached was one that a reasonable arbitrator could not have reached on the evidence.
The judge also pointed out that the arbitration award had not taken into account Mashabela’s 11 years service and his clean disciplinary record.
Rather than sending it back to the CCMA for another arbitration the court just decided the matter itself. It looked at the delay since Mashabela’s dismissal in July 2023 and found that the evidence was sufficient to decide the matter.
The court set aside the arbitration award, found the dismissal to be substantively unfair and ordered Makro to reinstate Mashabela immediately as Sales Manager: General Merchandise, or in a substantially similar position, on terms and conditions no less favourable than those which applied at the time of his dismissal.
Mashabela must report for duty within seven days of the order. There was no order in terms of cost.
Get your news on the go. Click here to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel.

