- A municipal refuse truck was left idling and unattended on Denne Avenue, Worcester, while its driver travelled in his supervisor’s private vehicle.
- Residents alerted a neighbourhood crime-watch group, and a retired diesel mechanic switched off the engine and removed the key.
- The Labour Court found that the driver had committed gross negligence, dishonesty and misconduct that brought the municipality into disrepute.
Residents in a Worcester neighbourhood had to step in to secure a municipal refuse truck after its driver left it running and unattended in the middle of the road, with the doors unlocked, windows open and keys in the ignition.
The incident happened on 26 March 2024 in Denne Avenue, Roux Park. The vehicle sat stationary with the engine idling for about 21 minutes. The case led to disciplinary action and a Labour Court dispute involving Breede Valley Local Municipality and its employee, Paul Opperman.
Driver leaves truck to travel in supervisor’s car
Opperman had worked for the municipality since March 2007 and was a Supervisor/Driver in the Solid Waste Department. He said he was dealing with a complaint about uncollected recycling bags on Jakaranda Street.
According to him, he had finished his regular duties and was headed to empty the refuse compactor when he decided to check for missed recycling collections. He parked the vehicle, registration BVM 29, in Denne Avenue near Worcester North NG Church, intending to walk to an electrical substation on a rugby field.
His supervisor, Superintendent Melissa Kafaar, arrived in her private silver BMW. Opperman said she told him to go with her to check if recycling bags had been missed. Electronic vehicle tracking showed “the compactor stayed stationary with the engine idling from 15:05:52 until 15:26:44”. The windows were open, doors unlocked, municipal logbooks and papers exposed on the seat, and the key left in the ignition.
Residents intervene to secure municipal property
At about 3.15pm, a resident photographed the unattended vehicle and posted an alert on the Worcester Crime Watch Neighbourhood WhatsApp group, which had over 1 000 members, including the executive mayor and ward councillors.
Tiana Botes, a retired resident and ward worker for Ward 6, arrived within minutes after being alerted. She called Councillor Botha, who asked her to stay at the scene and make sure the engine was off until municipal officials arrived.
Botes’s husband, Koos Botes, a retired diesel mechanic with more than 50 years’ experience on heavy trucks, climbed into the cab, turned off the engine and removed the key at about 3.26pm. Soon after, Kafaar’s BMW returned with Opperman.
Opperman questioned the residents about turning off the vehicle and wanted the key back. According to the evidence, he said he would need a special electronic tag from the workshop to restart the truck. But he was able to start it right away using the key.
Residents also testified that Opperman did not mention a recycling complaint when he returned. Instead, he reportedly said his boss had picked him up to show him something.
Conflicting explanations lead to disciplinary charges
The municipality charged Opperman with gross dishonesty, gross negligence and bringing the municipality into disrepute. The municipality disputed his explanation that he went with Kafaar to investigate uncollected recycling bags, pointing out inconsistencies in his story about where they went and why they left the compactor unattended.
Opperman first said he forgot the truck was running when he got into Kafaar’s car. But during cross-examination, he admitted he told her the engine was still idling before they drove off. The municipality was also concerned about the risk to its property and service delivery. The Solid Waste Department was already under pressure because of an ageing fleet of specialised compactors.
At least five operational compactors were needed to service Worcester on schedule, but only three were available on the morning of the incident. The disciplinary hearing found Opperman guilty of ordinary dishonesty, gross negligence and bringing the municipality into disrepute. He was dismissed on 26 September 2024.
Labour Court examines evidence
Opperman challenged his dismissal through the South African Local Government Bargaining Council. In December 2024, Commissioner C Jacobs found the dismissal procedurally fair but substantively unfair.
The arbitrator acquitted him of dishonesty and of bringing the municipality into disrepute, reducing the negligence charge to ordinary negligence. The arbitrator accepted that Opperman might simply have forgotten the truck was running and ordered his retrospective reinstatement without back pay, subject to a final written warning valid for 12 months. The municipality took the matter to the Labour Court.
In a judgment on 16 November 2026, Judge A. Lagrange found the arbitrator had misapplied the balance of probabilities test and failed to properly assess contradictions in Opperman’s evidence. The judge found Opperman’s admission that he knew the truck was still idling before leaving with Kafaar undercut his claim that he simply forgot about it.
Leaving a heavy municipal vehicle unattended on a public road for 21 minutes, with the engine running, windows open, doors unlocked and keys in the ignition, was an extreme departure from the required standard of care. The judge rejected the argument that the lack of actual damage meant the conduct was not serious. The important issue was the foreseeable risk of harm, not whether damage actually happened.
On the charge of bringing the municipality into disrepute, Judge Lagrange found the incident caused public alarm, required residents and councillors to step in to protect municipal property, and exposed the municipality to public ridicule.
Long service did not outweigh seriousness of misconduct
The judge considered Opperman’s 17 years and six months of service, clean record, age of 43 and responsibility as sole breadwinner for his wife and four children. The judgment also noted that the vehicle was not damaged and nothing was stolen.
However, the municipality’s Solid Waste Department was already struggling with an ageing fleet and a shortage of operational compactors. It needed at least five working compactors to keep up with Worcester’s collection schedule but had only three in the morning and four in the afternoon of the incident.
The judge noted that leaving one of these key vehicles running and unsecured exposed the municipality to the risk of losing a vital asset or suffering engine seizure damage estimated at between R200 000 and R300 000.
Judge Lagrange concluded that the combination of gross negligence, dishonesty and lack of real remorse destroyed the trust required for Opperman’s job. The Labour Court set aside the arbitration award and found his dismissal was substantively fair. No order was made as to costs.
Get your news on the go. Click here to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel.

