- Wayne Petersen and his teammates were denied prize money despite winning a golf competition because their scorecard did not contain their full surnames.
- Petersen claimed R20 000 for lost prize money, reputational harm and embarrassment in the Small Claims Court.
- The High Court set aside the R5 000 award, finding that the Commissioner had failed to provide reasons for her decision and that the nature of the damages claim required proper consideration.
A golfer who was disqualified from a competition and had to forfeit his prize money because his scorecard did not contain the players’ full names and surnames, as required by the rules, lost his legal battle for damages against the organiser and sponsor.
Eastern Cape resident Wayne Petersen initially approached the Small Claims Court, where he claimed R20 000 in damages, including lost prize money, reputational harm and embarrassment.
The Commissioner of the Small Claims Court awarded Petersen R5 000, payable by Kowie Toyota, the sponsor, and Royal Port Alfred Golf Club, the organiser of the tournament. The two parties approached the High Court in Makhanda to have the Small Claims Court’s decision reviewed.
Petersen, who was at the time the chairperson of the Humansdorp Development Golf Club, participated in the 18-hole Individual Stableford Competition and a four-ball Lions competition at the Royal Port Alfred Golf Club, in the Ndlambe district, in December last year.
The advertised competition rules required scorecards to contain the players’ full names (surnames and initials) to ensure they could be properly identified by the official. After the competition, it emerged that Petersen’s four-ball scorecard reflected only the players’ first names and initials representing their surnames.
Although they had won, Petersen and the other members of his team were not awarded the prize money. Petersen disputed the disqualification, maintaining that the players were clearly identifiable. He argued that there were no other players with the same first names in the competition, that the scorecard had been signed correctly and that the identities of all the players were known, verifiable and never in dispute.
Organiser and sponsor defend decision
The main defence by the organiser and sponsor was that the rules of golf and the competition rules had not been complied with. They further argued that it was not possible to identify the players from the scorecards and that, for this reason, the prize money had not been awarded to Petersen.
Regarding the R20 000 damages claim, the sponsor and organiser told the Small Claims Court that the claim was “absurd”, as it included compensation for lost prize money, reputational harm, public embarrassment at the prize-giving ceremony, emotional distress and humiliation.
The Commissioner, however, delivered a brief judgment without providing reasons and awarded Petersen R5 000 in compensation. The High Court initially referred the matter back to the Commissioner to obtain answers about her judgment, but she simply indicated that she had nothing to add.
Judge questions basis of damages claim
On review, the applicants, the organiser and sponsor, argued that the Commissioner had failed to place the parties under oath before receiving evidence and had proceeded to deliver judgment without properly engaging with or considering their submissions. They further argued that the Commissioner had failed to properly apply the club’s rules and the rules of golf.
Acting Judge BB Brody commented that a claim to enforce an alleged contractual entitlement to tournament prize money was distinguishable from a claim for compensation for injury to reputation arising from the circumstances in which a participant was disqualified.
“The references to reputational harm, public embarrassment, emotional distress and humiliation require careful consideration. Embarrassment and injured feelings do not, without more, establish that the cause of action is defamation. Equally, describing the relief as ‘damages’ cannot bring a claim for defamation within the (Small Claims Court’s) jurisdiction,” the judge said in upholding the review.
Get your news on the go. Click here to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel.

