Skip to content
Close Menu
ConvictionConviction
  • Home
  • Law & Justice
  • Special Reports
  • Opinion
  • Ask The Expert
  • Get In Touch

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

What's Hot

The return of Swart Gevaar: Black danger and why fear still rules white South Africa

November 19, 2026

Community schemes’ legal obligations intact despite CSOS shake-up

November 19, 2026

Immigration crackdown yields 38,982 deportations and 4,370 arrests in seven months

November 19, 2026
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Trending
  • The return of Swart Gevaar: Black danger and why fear still rules white South Africa
  • Community schemes’ legal obligations intact despite CSOS shake-up
  • Immigration crackdown yields 38,982 deportations and 4,370 arrests in seven months
  • Advocate Du Plessis faces attempted murder prosecution for 2023 road rage incident
  • Mortgage bond puts property developer’s eviction powers in question
  • Attorney who attempted to halt maintenance orders faces punitive costs
  • Six months of inactivity does not automatically end a labour review
  • Makro manager dismissed for buying pies at R7 instead of R283 secures reinstatement
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
ConvictionConviction
Sonneblom
  • Home
  • Law & Justice
  • Special Reports
  • Opinion
  • Ask The Expert
  • Get In Touch
ConvictionConviction
Home » RAF lost earnings claim
Civil Law

Motorist loses R4.3m RAF claim due to insufficient, speculative evidence

A North West High Court judge dismissed a motorist’s claim for past and future lost earnings, finding that expert projections were unsupported by objective evidence of his income and career prospects.
Kennedy MudzuliBy Kennedy MudzuliNovember 18, 2026No Comments
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Tumblr Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email
  • The RAF was found fully liable for injuries suffered by a motorist in a 2020 accident involving a truck.
  • The motorist’s claim for R4.3 million in past and future loss of earnings was dismissed because he did not provide enough proof of his financial losses.
  • The judge found that expert reports relied on speculation, and the actuary’s calculations, based on their flawed assessment, could not be accepted.

A motorist who proved that a truck driver caused a collision has failed to secure R4.3 million in lost earnings. The judge found that the financial projections supporting his claim were based on speculation and lacked sufficient evidence.

In reasons released on 17 November 2026, Acting Judge T Masike of the North West High Court in Mahikeng dismissed Mogorosi Donald Ditagwe’s claim for past and future loss of earnings. The judge found that Ditagwe did not prove that his accident-related injuries would harm his future earning capacity.

Collision left motorist with serious injuries

Ditagwe was involved in a crash on 22 November 2020 while driving a Hyundai Getz on the Lichtenburg-Koster road. He testified that he was behind another vehicle when a truck ahead suddenly attempted a right turn without indicating. The vehicle in front managed to overtake the truck, but Ditagwe crashed into it while trying to avoid the sudden manoeuvre.

He suffered fractures to both upper arms, multiple rib fractures, an injury to his right big toe, and other soft tissue injuries. He underwent surgery on both arms and was hospitalised at Mahikeng Provincial Hospital. He later claimed against the Road Accident Fund (RAF) for medical expenses, general damages, and loss of earning capacity.

His original claim included R50 000 for past loss and R300 000 for future loss of earning capacity. In August 2025, he amended his claim, increasing the future loss of earnings to R4 316 821. The RAF defended the case but did not appear when it went to trial.

Judge Masike accepted Ditagwe’s account of the accident and found that the truck driver had failed to keep a proper lookout, failed to avoid the collision when he reasonably could have, and made an unsafe right turn without indicating. The RAF was held fully liable for proven or agreed damages from the accident.

Missing documents undermine past earnings claim

The first major problem was proving what Ditagwe earned before the crash. He told industrial psychologists that he had worked as an agent for Emerald Life Insurance and earned about R15 000 a month. However, he could not provide payslips, bank statements, or any documents to back up this amount.

Although he supplied IRP5 tax certificates for 2021 to 2025, he did not provide tax records for 2020, the year of the collision. The judge also noted that orthopaedic surgeon Dr MB Deacon had recorded that Ditagwe received his full salary while away from work after the accident, a detail that was not properly addressed in the psychologists’ report.

Judge Masike was not convinced that the claimed R15 000 monthly income was proven, finding the claim was based only on Ditagwe’s own word. The court concluded that he had not proved any past loss of earnings.

Rising income challenges future loss projections

The judge also questioned the basis for the future earnings claim. Ditagwe’s tax certificates showed that his income actually rose sharply after the accident, from R9 968 in 2021 to R223 351 in 2022, R381 947 in 2023, R534 666 in 2024, and R758 842 in 2025.

Despite this increase, the industrial psychologists argued that his injuries put him at risk of missing sales targets, facing disciplinary action, losing his job, or taking early retirement. They also said his physical limitations affected his ability to do his job and compete for other work. However, the judge found these claims were not supported by objective evidence.

The psychologists had spoken to Hannelie Pieterse, Emerald Life’s branch manager, who confirmed that Ditagwe sometimes experienced pain when driving long distances and occasionally stayed home while his team travelled. But Pieterse also said he continued to meet his sales targets and had not received any further warnings after an earlier performance warning had expired. She also noted that he was showing positive career development and had the potential to increase his earnings.

Judge Masike found that the manager’s evidence did not support the experts’ predictions of discipline, demotion, or early retirement. The judge held that the psychologists’ opinions were speculative and not backed by evidence, especially since Ditagwe continued to meet his targets despite his reported difficulties.

Actuary’s R4.3m calculation rejected

Actuary Johan Potgieter calculated Ditagwe’s past and future loss of earnings at R4 316 821. His calculations were based on the psychologists’ estimates of what Ditagwe would have earned if not for the accident, compared to his anticipated earnings after the injuries.

Potgieter made it clear that his calculations did not endorse the psychologists’ income scenarios and that he relied entirely on their assessment. Judge Masike found that because the expert report was speculative, the actuarial calculations based on it could also not be accepted.

The judge also questioned the assumptions about Ditagwe’s possible career as a diesel mechanic. Although Ditagwe said he held a National Diploma in Diesel Mechanics, he could not produce the certificate. The experts admitted the proof was missing but still included the proposed mechanical career in their assessment. The judge found this was another flaw in their report.

Claim dismissed despite RAF liability

In weighing the claim, Judge Masike referred to Southern Insurance Association Limited v Bailey NO, which recognises that assessing loss of earning capacity involves estimating future earnings. However, the judgment stressed that estimates cannot replace evidence where information is available to the claimant.

The judge also referred to Mlotshwa v Road Accident Fund, which highlights the duty on claimants to provide enough proof of their earnings, even when income comes from informal work. While courts recognise the realities of informal employment, claimants still must show their financial losses.

Ditagwe’s failure to prove his pre-accident income, combined with a lack of evidence showing his injuries would harm his future career, proved fatal to his claim. The court dismissed his claim for past and future loss of earnings.

The RAF was still ordered to give an undertaking under section 17(4)(a) of the Road Accident Fund Act for future medical treatment and related expenses. The question of general damages was separated from the other issues and postponed indefinitely. The RAF was also ordered to pay the plaintiff’s legal costs.

Conviction.co.za

Get your news on the go. Click here to follow the Conviction WhatsApp channel.

expert evidence Loss of Earnings North West High Court personal injury claims Road Accident Fund
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Telegram Email
Kennedy Mudzuli

Multiple award-winner with passion for news and training young journalists. Founder and editor of Conviction.co.za

Related Posts

Mangaung ordered to remove R170 000 water debt dating back to 2013

November 18, 2026

Buffalo, diesel and cattle medicine theft allegations at centre of harassment case

November 18, 2026

Golfer loses prize money after scorecard fails to meet competition rules

November 17, 2026
Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Prove your humanity: 4   +   2   =  

Subscribe to our newsletter:
Top Posts

Your driving licence at the gate: What estates can actually legally scan

Sponsor: My Estate LifeSeptember 6, 2026

Making sectional title rules that work: A practical guide

January 17, 2025

Protection order among the consequences of trespassing in an ‘Exclusive Use Area’

December 31, 2024

Between a rock and a foul-smelling place

November 27, 2024
Don't Miss
Opinion
6 Mins Read

The return of Swart Gevaar: Black danger and why fear still rules white South Africa

By Sandile MemelaNovember 19, 20266 Mins Read

The prospect of a black-led political coalition has reopened South Africa’s historical racial anxieties, raising questions about political power, economic control and accountability.

Community schemes’ legal obligations intact despite CSOS shake-up

November 19, 2026

Immigration crackdown yields 38,982 deportations and 4,370 arrests in seven months

November 19, 2026

Advocate Du Plessis faces attempted murder prosecution for 2023 road rage incident

November 19, 2026
Stay In Touch
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • WhatsApp
Demo
About Us
About Us

Helping South Africans to navigate the legal landscape; providing accessible legal information; and giving a voice to those seeking justice.

Facebook X (Twitter) YouTube WhatsApp Twitch RSS
Latest posts

Your driving licence at the gate: What estates can actually legally scan

Sponsor: My Estate LifeSeptember 6, 2026

Making sectional title rules that work: A practical guide

January 17, 2025

Protection order among the consequences of trespassing in an ‘Exclusive Use Area’

December 31, 2024
OUR PICKS

Two employees dismissed for secretly recording a workplace meeting via cellphone

November 9, 2026

UNISA secures interim interdict against ‘Lawyers from Unisa be like’ social media videos

November 14, 2026

UNISA lawyers are the best: Graduate collects amended degree certificate after legal battle

November 17, 2026
© 2026 Conviction.
  • Home
  • Buy Now
  • Law & Justice

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

Powered by
Necessary cookies enable essential site features like secure log-ins and consent preference adjustments. They do not store personal data.
None
Functional cookies support features like content sharing on social media, collecting feedback, and enabling third-party tools.
None
Analytical cookies track visitor interactions, providing insights on metrics like visitor count, bounce rate, and traffic sources.
None
Advertisement cookies deliver personalized ads based on your previous visits and analyze the effectiveness of ad campaigns.
None
Unclassified cookies are cookies that we are in the process of classifying, together with the providers of individual cookies.
None
Powered by